Fiscal policy and the Union Budget

Economics (BA) · Macroeconomics · free study notes for exams, placements and interviews

In short

Fiscal policy is the government's use of taxation, expenditure and borrowing to influence aggregate demand, output, employment, prices and the distribution of income. In India it is delivered chiefly through the Union Budget - the Annual Financial Statement laid before Parliament under Article 112 of the Constitution - supported by the Finance Bill, the Appropriation Bill and the fiscal targets of the FRBM Act, 2003. The topic carries heavy weight in BA/MA macroeconomics papers, in UGC-NET and Indian Economic Service papers, and in RBI Grade B, NABARD, SEBI and bank PO interviews, where candidates are expected to quote the current deficit numbers and explain the deficit arithmetic. Analysts in rating agencies, banks' treasury desks and policy think-tanks use exactly this framework every February. Budget magnitudes change each year, so learn the *structure and arithmetic* first and refresh the numbers from the latest Budget at a Glance.

Explained

What fiscal policy is, and its instruments

Instruments: (a) taxation - direct (income tax, corporation tax) and indirect (GST, customs, excise on petroleum); (b) public expenditure - revenue and capital; (c) public debt and its management; (d) transfers and subsidies.
Objectives: full employment and growth, price stability, reduction of inequality, balanced regional development, and (post-1991) fiscal sustainability.
Expansionary fiscal policy: raise G or cut T to lift aggregate demand in a slowdown - raises the fiscal deficit. Contractionary (fiscal consolidation): cut G or raise T to cool demand or rebuild fiscal space.
Discretionary vs automatic: discretionary measures need a Budget or an Act; automatic stabilisers work without any decision - progressive tax collections fall and rural employment guarantee (VB-G RAM G, formerly MGNREGS) and subsidy outgo rises in a downturn, cushioning demand (critics argue the 2025 Act's normative State-wise allocations make it less demand-driven than MGNREGA was).
Counter-cyclical policy stabilises the cycle; pro-cyclical policy (spending more in booms, cutting in busts because revenue collapses) amplifies it and is a common developing-country failing.
Fiscal impulse / stance: the change in the primary deficit (cyclically adjusted) measures whether policy is adding to or withdrawing demand, independently of what the cycle itself did to revenues.
Limitations: recognition, decision and implementation lags; crowding out of private investment when borrowing raises interest rates; leakages into imports; Ricardian equivalence (consumers save a tax cut expecting future taxes); political difficulty of reversing a giveaway; rigidity of committed expenditure (interest, salaries, pensions, subsidies) which leaves little discretionary room.

The Union Budget: constitutional and legal frame

Article 112: the President causes an Annual Financial Statement of estimated receipts and expenditure for the financial year (1 April-31 March) to be laid before both Houses. Presented on 1 February (changed from the last working day of February in 2017), paperless since 2021.
Article 265: no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law - hence the Finance Bill. Article 114: no money withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund except under an Appropriation Act.
Article 110: the Finance Bill and Appropriation Bill are Money Bills - introduced only in the Lok Sabha, on the President's recommendation; the Rajya Sabha may only recommend changes and must return the Bill within 14 days. The Speaker certifies a Bill as a Money Bill.
Three funds: Consolidated Fund of India (Art. 266) - all revenues, loans raised and recoveries; Contingency Fund (Art. 267) - at the President's disposal for unforeseen spending, placed with the Finance Secretary; Public Account (Art. 266(2)) - provident funds, small savings, reserve funds where government is a banker, so most of it needs no vote.
Charged expenditure (interest and debt servicing, emoluments of the President, salaries and allowances of the presiding officers of both Houses, salaries of Supreme Court judges and pensions of Supreme Court and High Court judges, the CAG, Election Commissioners) is not votable - only discussed. The rest is votable as Demands for Grants.
Audit and accountability: the CAG (Articles 148-151) audits and reports; the Public Accounts Committee and Estimates Committee examine the reports. The Budget's own numbers appear as BE (Budget Estimate), RE (Revised Estimate) and Actuals.
Other grants: Supplementary, Additional and Excess grants (Article 115) and Exceptional grants, Vote of Credit and Vote on Account (Article 116); a Vote on Account authorises spending for part of the year; an Interim Budget is presented in an election year.

Budget documents and classification of receipts and expenditure

Key documents: Annual Financial Statement; Demands for Grants; Finance Bill; Budget at a Glance; Receipt Budget; Expenditure Budget and Profile; Macro-Economic Framework Statement, Medium-Term Fiscal Policy cum Fiscal Policy Strategy Statement (both mandated by the FRBM Act); Output-Outcome Framework; Statement of Revenue Impact of Tax Incentives ("revenue forgone"); Gender Budget and Child Budget statements; Implementation of Budget Announcements.
Receipts:
Revenue receipts - do not create a liability or reduce an asset: tax revenue (corporation tax, income tax, GST, customs, Union excise duties, cesses and surcharges) and non-tax revenue (RBI/PSU dividends, interest, spectrum and licence fees, user charges).
Capital receipts - debt-creating (market borrowing through dated securities, T-bills, small savings from the NSSF, external loans) and non-debt (recovery of loans, disinvestment/other miscellaneous capital receipts).
Expenditure:
Revenue expenditure - no asset created: interest payments, subsidies (food, fertiliser, petroleum), salaries, pensions, defence revenue, grants to states for current use.
Capital expenditure - creates assets or reduces liabilities: roads, railways, metros, defence capital, loans to states for capex. Also reported as effective capital expenditure = capex + grants-in-aid to states for creation of capital assets.
The Plan/non-Plan distinction was abolished from 2017-18 (with the Planning Commission's replacement by NITI Aayog); the Railway Budget was merged into the Union Budget the same year. Only the revenue/capital classification survives.
Types of budget: balanced (R = E), surplus, deficit. Techniques: line-item/incremental, zero-base budgeting (every item justified afresh), performance and outcome budgeting, gender budgeting, and cash-basis accounting (India is on cash basis, not accrual).

The deficits - definitions and what each tells you

Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts. Borrowing used for consumption; it adds to debt without adding to assets, so it is the quality-of-deficit indicator.
Effective revenue deficit = revenue deficit − grants to states for creation of capital assets (introduced by the FRBM amendment of 2012).
Fiscal deficit = total expenditure − (revenue receipts + non-debt capital receipts) = the government's net borrowing requirement in the year. The headline number, the one rating agencies watch.
Primary deficit = fiscal deficit − interest payments. Strips out the cost of past borrowing and shows the current year's own imbalance.
Monetised deficit = RBI's net credit to government. Automatic monetisation through ad hoc Treasury Bills was ended in 1997 and replaced by Ways and Means Advances; under the FRBM Act the RBI cannot subscribe to primary issues of central government securities except under the escape clause.
Off-budget / extra-budgetary resources: borrowing by FCI, NHAI, oil marketing companies etc. serviced from the Budget - it understates the true deficit. Largely brought on-budget after 2020-21.
Financing: gross market borrowing via dated G-secs and T-bills, small savings, state provident funds, external assistance, and drawdown of cash balances. Gross borrowing = net borrowing + repayments of maturing debt.

Fiscal rules: the FRBM Act and the debt anchor

FRBM Act, 2003 (rules 2004): required elimination of the revenue deficit and a fiscal deficit of 3% of GDP, annual reduction targets, three statements with the Budget, and quarterly reviews laid before Parliament (Section 7); medium-term expenditure framework statement presented separately in the monsoon session.
N. K. Singh FRBM Review Committee (2017) recommended a debt-to-GDP anchor - 40% for the Centre, 20% for states, 60% general government - with the fiscal deficit as the operational target. The 2018 amendment set a fiscal deficit of 3% by 31 March 2021 and the 40% central debt ceiling, with an escape clause (deviation up to 0.5% of GDP for national security, calamity, structural reform or a sharp output collapse).
Targets were breached in the pandemic: the central fiscal deficit reached about 9.2% of GDP in 2020-21, after which a glide path to below 4.5% by 2025-26 was announced and met.
From 2026-27 the Centre's stated anchor shifted to central government debt as a share of GDP - declining to roughly 50% ± 1% by 2030-31 - with the yearly fiscal deficit kept consistent with that path rather than being a fixed 3%.
States: bound by their own FRL Acts and by Article 293(3) - a state indebted to the Centre needs its consent to borrow; the net borrowing ceiling is generally 3% of GSDP, with extra space tied to power-sector reform and capex-linked interest-free loans to states.

Fiscal federalism: who taxes, who spends

Finance Commission (Article 280): constituted every five years to recommend the vertical share of central taxes to states, horizontal distribution among them, and grants-in-aid (Article 275). The 15th FC (2021-26) fixed the states' share of the divisible pool at 41%. The 16th Finance Commission (chaired by Arvind Panagariya, constituted December 2023) covers 2026-27 to 2030-31; its devolution share and grant structure should be read from the accepted report and the Action Taken Report, as the figures supersede the 15th FC's.
Cesses and surcharges are not shareable, so a rising share of them shrinks the divisible pool - a standing state grievance.
GST and Article 279A: the GST Council, chaired by the Union Finance Minister, decides rates; the Centre has one-third and states two-thirds of the weighted votes, with decisions by a three-fourths majority. Since 22 September 2025 the main slabs are 5%, 18% and 40% (plus nil-rated items and the special rate on bullion); the compensation cess regime has ended. IGST on inter-state supply is apportioned between Centre and states.
Direct taxes: the Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the Income-tax Act, 1961 with effect from 1 April 2026, renumbering sections and forms; the substance of the concessional "new regime" slabs, standard deduction for salaried taxpayers and rebate continue, but quote the 2025 Act's provisions by name unless the current numbering is confirmed.
Other fiscal bodies: the Department of Economic Affairs (Budget Division), the Public Debt Management Cell, and the Fifteenth/Sixteenth FC-mandated frameworks; the Economic Survey is prepared by the Chief Economic Adviser and tabled in Parliament by the Finance Minister, conventionally a day before the Budget.

The budget cycle, step by step

September-October: Budget circular issued; ministries submit estimates; pre-Budget consultations with industry, farm bodies, economists and state finance ministers.
December-January: Expenditure Secretary's meetings; revenue estimates finalised; RE for the current year settled.
1 February, 11 a.m.: Finance Minister presents the Budget in the Lok Sabha; documents go live on the Union Budget portal and app.
General discussion on the Budget as a whole (no voting), then recess while Departmentally Related Standing Committees scrutinise each ministry's Demands for Grants.
Voting on Demands for Grants ministry by ministry; members may move cut motions - disapproval of policy (reduce to ₹1), economy cut, or token cut (₹100). Remaining demands are put to vote together by the guillotine.
Appropriation Bill authorises withdrawal from the Consolidated Fund; the Finance Bill enacts the tax proposals - both must be passed before 1 April.
During the year: supplementary demands, quarterly FRBM reviews, monthly accounts from the Controller General of Accounts; afterwards, CAG audit and PAC examination.

Key points

Fiscal policy - use of taxation, spending and borrowing to influence output, employment, prices and distribution.
Annual Financial Statement - the Budget proper, laid under Article 112; a Money Bill under Article 110.
Revenue receipt - no liability created and no asset reduced; capital receipt - creates a liability (borrowing) or reduces an asset (disinvestment).
Revenue expenditure - creates no asset (interest, subsidies, salaries); capital expenditure - creates an asset or repays debt.
Fiscal deficit - total expenditure minus revenue receipts and non-debt capital receipts; equals net borrowing for the year.
Revenue deficit - borrowing to meet consumption; the indicator of deficit *quality*.
Primary deficit - fiscal deficit minus interest payments; a zero primary deficit means current spending is covered and only old debt is being serviced.
Automatic stabilisers - progressive taxes and welfare spending that cushion the cycle without a fresh decision.
Crowding out - government borrowing raising interest rates and displacing private investment.
FRBM Act, 2003 - statutory fiscal targets, three mandated statements, escape clause; amended 2012 and 2018.
Escape clause - permitted deviation of up to 0.5% of GDP for calamity, national security, structural reform or a collapse in output.
Debt anchor - central government debt as a share of GDP, targeted at about 50% ± 1% by 2030-31, replacing a fixed deficit rule from 2026-27.
Finance Commission (Art. 280) - fixes the states' share of central taxes; 41% under the 15th FC for 2021-26, with the 16th FC's award running 2026-27 to 2030-31.
Cesses and surcharges - excluded from the divisible pool, so they reduce states' effective share.
GST Council (Art. 279A) - Centre one-third, states two-thirds of votes, three-fourths majority; slabs 5/18/40% since 22 September 2025.
Vote on Account vs Interim Budget - the first authorises spending only; the second is a full set of estimates without major tax changes.
Guillotine - the Speaker putting all outstanding Demands for Grants to vote together when time runs out.
Tax buoyancy - percentage growth in tax revenue per percentage growth in nominal GDP; above 1 means revenue is outpacing the economy.

Formulas and examples

Revenue deficit (RD) = Revenue expenditure − Revenue receipts (₹ crore, or % of GDP)
Effective revenue deficit = RD − Grants to states for creation of capital assets
Fiscal deficit (FD) = Total expenditure − (Revenue receipts + Non-debt capital receipts) = Net borrowing
Primary deficit (PD) = FD − Interest payments
Deficit as % of GDP = (Deficit ÷ Nominal GDP at current market prices) × 100
Gross market borrowing = Net market borrowing + Repayment of maturing securities
Debt dynamics: Δd = [(r − g)/(1 + g)] × d − pb, where d = debt/GDP, r = nominal effective interest rate, g = nominal GDP growth, pb = primary balance as % of GDP (negative for a primary deficit)
Government spending multiplier (open economy, with taxes) = 1 / [1 − c(1 − t) + m]; tax multiplier = −c / [1 − c(1 − t) + m]
Balanced-budget multiplier = 1 (when ΔG = ΔT, closed economy, lump-sum tax)
Tax buoyancy = (% change in tax revenue) ÷ (% change in nominal GDP)
Fiscal impulse ≈ − Δ(primary balance as % of GDP); positive value = expansionary stance

Example 1 - Computing all three deficits (Union Budget 2025-26, Budget Estimates; figures in ₹ lakh crore).

Item	Amount
Revenue receipts (net tax 28.37 + non-tax 5.83)	34.20
Non-debt capital receipts	0.76
Revenue expenditure	39.44
Capital expenditure	11.21
Interest payments	12.76
Nominal GDP assumed	357

Total expenditure = 39.44 + 11.21 = ₹50.65 lakh crore
Receipts excluding borrowing = 34.20 + 0.76 = ₹34.96 lakh crore
FD = 50.65 − 34.96 = ₹15.69 lakh crore = 15.69/357 × 100 = 4.4% of GDP
RD = 39.44 − 34.20 = ₹5.23 lakh crore = 1.5% of GDP
PD = 15.69 − 12.76 = ₹2.93 lakh crore = 0.8% of GDP
Reading: interest payments alone absorb 12.76/34.20 = 37% of revenue receipts, and 81% of the fiscal deficit - which is why the primary deficit is small even when the fiscal deficit looks large. (Replace with the latest year's Budget at a Glance when quoting current numbers.)

Example 2 - Debt sustainability. Central debt d = 57% of GDP, nominal GDP growth g = 10%, average nominal interest on debt r = 7.3%, primary deficit = 0.8% of GDP (so pb = −0.8).

Δd = [(0.073 − 0.10)/1.10] × 57 − (−0.8) = (−0.02455) × 57 + 0.8 = −1.40 + 0.8 = −0.60 percentage points
Debt falls to about 56.4% of GDP. Because g > r, growth does the work; a primary deficit of up to 1.4% of GDP would have kept debt flat. If growth slowed to 7% while r stayed at 7.3%, Δd = (0.003/1.07)×57 + 0.8 = +0.96 pp - debt would start rising.

Example 3 - Capital vs revenue spending multiplier. Government shifts ₹1 lakh crore from a revenue subsidy (multiplier 0.45) to capital expenditure (multiplier 2.45, the order of magnitude found in Indian studies).

Output lost from the subsidy cut = 0.45 × 1 = ₹0.45 lakh crore; gained from capex = 2.45 × 1 = ₹2.45 lakh crore
Net gain in GDP = ₹2.00 lakh crore, with no change in the fiscal deficit - the arithmetic behind India's push to raise the capex share of expenditure (11.21/50.65 = 22% in 2025-26 BE).
If the Centre's gross tax-to-GDP ratio is 12%, the extra ₹2.00 lakh crore of GDP returns 0.12 × 2.00 = ₹0.24 lakh crore of taxes, so the deficit actually improves.

Example 4 - Tax buoyancy. Gross tax revenue rises from ₹38.40 to ₹42.70 lakh crore while nominal GDP grows 10.1%.

Tax growth = (42.70 − 38.40)/38.40 × 100 = 11.2%
Buoyancy = 11.2 ÷ 10.1 = 1.11 - revenue growing faster than the economy, through better compliance and formalisation rather than new rates.

Example 5 - Balanced-budget multiplier. MPC c = 0.8, closed economy; government raises both G and lump-sum T by ₹500 crore.

From spending: 1/(1 − 0.8) = 5 → ΔY = +₹2,500 crore
From the tax rise: −0.8/0.2 = −4 → ΔY = −₹2,000 crore
Net ΔY = +₹500 crore = ΔG, so the balanced-budget multiplier is 1 - a tax-financed spending increase still raises output, because the tax only cuts spending by c times the amount.

Indicator	Formula	What it signals
Revenue deficit	Rev. expenditure − Rev. receipts	Borrowing for consumption - poor quality
Fiscal deficit	Total exp. − (Rev. receipts + non-debt capital receipts)	Total net borrowing, pressure on interest rates
Primary deficit	FD − Interest payments	Current-year imbalance, excluding past debt
Monetised deficit	RBI's net credit to government	Inflationary financing (curtailed since 1997)

Where it is used

Economic research and ratings: sovereign analysts at CRISIL, ICRA, CARE, S&P and Moody's model the deficit, borrowing calendar and debt path every February; think-tanks such as NIPFP and NCAER do the multiplier and devolution work.
Banking and treasury: G-sec desks price the gross borrowing programme announced with the Budget; bank economists publish Budget notes within hours. Roles: fixed-income analyst, treasury dealer, macro research associate.
Government and regulators: Indian Economic Service and Indian Revenue Service officers, DEA Budget Division, RBI Grade B (DEPR), state finance departments preparing GSDP-linked borrowing plans, Finance Commission and GST Council secretariats.
Corporate and tax advisory: Big Four and law firms issue Finance Bill impact analyses for clients; FICCI, CII and ASSOCHAM prepare pre-Budget memoranda.
Media and content: Budget desks at Business Standard, Mint, Economic Times, and explainer content for investor platforms.
Public finance practice: municipal and state budget analysis, scheme-level outcome budgeting, and capex-linked interest-free loan proposals from states to the Centre.

Interview questions

Q: What is the difference between fiscal deficit and revenue deficit? A: The fiscal deficit is total borrowing - expenditure minus revenue receipts and non-debt capital receipts. The revenue deficit is only the shortfall on the revenue account, so it measures borrowing used for consumption rather than asset creation.
Q: Why do economists watch the primary deficit? A: It removes interest payments on past borrowing and so shows whether this year's own fiscal operations are in balance; a zero primary deficit means new borrowing only services old debt.
Q: When is a rising debt-to-GDP ratio sustainable? A: When nominal GDP growth exceeds the effective nominal interest rate on debt, the ratio can fall even with a modest primary deficit - the condition in the debt-dynamics equation Δd = [(r − g)/(1+g)]d − pb.
Q: What are automatic stabilisers, and give an Indian example? A: Features that cushion the cycle without fresh decisions - progressive income tax collections fall in a slowdown, while rural employment guarantee wage demand (VB-G RAM G, formerly MGNREGS) and food subsidy outgo rise automatically.
Q: What is crowding out, and is it serious in India? A: Heavy government borrowing can raise interest rates and displace private investment; it bites when capacity is tight, but is weaker when banks hold surplus liquidity and private investment demand is slack.
Q: Why is capital expenditure favoured over revenue expenditure? A: Its multiplier is estimated at several times that of revenue spending, and it creates assets that raise future productive capacity, so the same deficit buys more growth.
Q: What is a Money Bill and how does it limit the Rajya Sabha? A: A Bill confined to taxation, borrowing and the Consolidated Fund under Article 110; it originates in the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha can only make recommendations and must return it within 14 days.
Q: What is the escape clause in the FRBM Act? A: It permits deviation from the fiscal deficit target by up to 0.5% of GDP on specified grounds - national security, calamity, farm collapse, structural reform or a sharp fall in output - with reasons reported to Parliament.
Q: Why do states object to cesses and surcharges? A: They are not part of the divisible pool shared under the Finance Commission's award, so revenue raised through them bypasses devolution and shrinks the states' effective share.
Q: What is the difference between a Vote on Account and an Interim Budget? A: A Vote on Account only authorises expenditure for part of the year from the Consolidated Fund; an Interim Budget presents full estimates of receipts and expenditure, conventionally without major tax changes.
Q: If a government raises both spending and taxes by the same amount, what happens to output? A: Output still rises - the balanced-budget multiplier is 1, because the spending increase acts in full while the tax rise reduces consumption only by the MPC times that amount.
Q: Can the RBI finance the fiscal deficit directly? A: Automatic monetisation through ad hoc T-bills ended in 1997, and the FRBM Act bars the RBI from buying primary issues of central G-secs except under the escape clause; it can still buy in the secondary market through OMOs.

Common mistakes

Adding borrowing to receipts and then computing the fiscal deficit - borrowing *is* the deficit, so it is excluded from the receipts side.
Treating disinvestment proceeds as revenue receipts; they are non-debt capital receipts (an asset is reduced).
Calling loan repayment by the government a revenue expenditure - repayment of principal is capital expenditure, while interest is revenue expenditure.
Writing fiscal deficit = revenue deficit + capital expenditure; that only holds if non-debt capital receipts are zero, which they never are.
Quoting deficits in ₹ crore when the question asks for a percentage of GDP, or mixing a year's BE with another year's actuals in the same comparison.
Saying a high fiscal deficit is always bad - the composition matters: a deficit financing capital expenditure with g > r differs sharply from one financing subsidies.
Confusing the Finance Commission (Article 280, tax devolution) with the GST Council (Article 279A, rates), or the Finance Bill (taxes) with the Appropriation Bill (withdrawals).
Repeating the 15th Finance Commission's 41% devolution share for a period after 2025-26 without checking the 16th Commission's accepted award.